2

Likewise many sites of StackExchange family (and even the very StackOverflow), we should decide the unified style for tags.

Should we prefer singular or plural in tags, in cases where both would make sense?

For example:

4

At first I thought that simply plural was the answer, but it seems like in order to follow the conventions of other sites we might need a more complicated rule.

For example, whole other sites have a "nouns" tag instead of just "noun", they don't have an "orthographies" tag, the have an "orthography" tag.

My best attempt at describing this rule would be to say that whichever number sounds like the best fit in this sentence:

I have a question about ________

or in Ukrainian:

________ є предметом мого питання

  • Hmmm. Great observation and a useful rule of thumb. However — "…in cases where both would make sense": is there an example word that would have both singular and plural forms, and the singular were better for tag? – bytebuster Feb 14 '17 at 3:19
  • @bytebuster I'd be happy to expand my answer. Could you give an example of such a case? – FracturedRetina Feb 14 '17 at 5:26
  • Sorry, this must be due to my poor wording. :-) I mean, my question says, "…in cases where both would make sense" — so "orthography" is out of the scope of my question, because this is not the case where both "orthography" and "orthographies" would make sense. – bytebuster Feb 14 '17 at 5:36
2

My own preference is —

Plural

because:

  • This seems to be a mainstream;
  • Other sites like Wikipedia often use plural for categories;
-1

I'd say we should decide different cases individually:

  • parts of speech — I'd say plural;
  • (also antonym, homonym) — I'd say plural;
  • other future cases — to decide.

Why I vote for plural for parts of speech and for synonym/antonym/homonym:

Though argument about category names Wikipedia doesn't works fully, because (say) for parts of speech:

(Still, Russian and Ukrainian Wikipedias might just not normalized it yet, as they're smaller than English and can't pay attention to every category name.)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .