2

I've seen a ПІЄ abbreviation in the answer on one of my questions today, and I had to ask for the explanation. It appeared to be Праіндоєвропейська мова.

I didn't know it, so I had to ask.

Perhaps, we need a thread where everyone will be able to add their abbreviations to make the understanding of answers easier?

Wiki-answer would be a good solution, as for me.

3

ПІЄ/PIE – is a very widespread abbreviation every linguist knows, just like OCS, "Old Church Slavonic". But since not only linguists visit our SE (StackExchange), the best strategy is to avoid abbreviations which are not explained in the text itself. As for me, I would never use unexplained abbreviations, if I use a long term often in my Q/A (question or answer), I will use it in full for the first time and write in brackets the abbreviation I ascribe to it, only then I will use the abbreviation in the text I write. That is the strategy I recommend to everyone. Naturally, common English language abbreviations like "&", "etc.", "e.g." do not count. As for the Internet abbreviations like "AFAIN" (for "as far as I know") and the like, I think they should not be used here at all and the moderators must correct them into the full phrases.

  • We can also put the abbreviation and link it to the correspondent URL, for example. – P. Vowk Mar 6 '17 at 12:14
  • Making a person go somewhere to learn what you could have written in a couple of words looks far from good manners. :) – Yellow Sky Mar 6 '17 at 12:23
  • I agree, makes sense – P. Vowk Mar 6 '17 at 12:28
0

I think we should not use abbreviations in answers. To make them readable for wide audience.

Of course, it is not crucial — better an answer with abbreviations than no answer (or a bad answer). And not always easy: sometimes we hurry, sometimes we mistakenly consider something as obvious (e.g. SUM-11) and intuitively don't even realize the problem with it. But the best is not to use abbreviations (I mean: not explained within the post itself). In practice: to write as you can, but remove/describe abbreviation as soon as somebody asks "what it it" — instead of considering it as problem of those who doesn't know something.

I.e. it's ok to make a list of abbreviations for ourselves (to share that knowledge between ourselves). But it's not ok to make a list of abbreviations with the intention "to use later these abbreviations in questions and answers without explanations, pointing users to that list instead of correctly decorating the posts". In my humble opinion.

  • Sorry, but -1. We shouldn't get wild with abbreviations, but neither should we ban them totally. There must be some reasonable limit instead. Otherwise, someone would consider "IMHO" an incomprehensible abbreviation. – bytebuster Mar 26 '17 at 16:53
  • @bytebuster, I consider "IMHO" as totally ok in comment, but not very good in answer. As a stated ("write as you can, but remove/describe abbreviation as soon as somebody asks 'what it it'"), I'm not against abbreviations totally, but the less abbreviations are in an answer — the wider audience can read it without problems (of course, that should not be by the cost of answer quality or answer existence). – Sasha Mar 26 '17 at 17:17
  • But… your IMHO is precisely in the answer, not in comment. And I.e., too. That's why I consider "I think we should not use abbreviations in answers" a too strong statement. – bytebuster Mar 26 '17 at 17:20
  • @bytebuster, (1) it's the Meta, not the main site (it's our local zone). (2) As I've said, I'm not totally against (just "try use less, if it doesn't reduces quality or existence-probability of your answer"). (3) I explain it per you request :). – Sasha Mar 26 '17 at 17:30
  • @bytebuster, i.e. — you're right, there are some very common (not field-specific and not jargon/argo) abbreviations, like: i.e., etc, e.g., і т.д., і т.п., і т.і., etc. Probably they are exceptions (although OnlineCorrector recommends to replace some of them too). – Sasha Mar 26 '17 at 17:34

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .